top of page
Fall 2025 Holiday MenuAll of your fall favorites, all scratch-made -- Take it easy and let us do the heavy lifting!


Order Cutoff date: Thursday, 11/20/25 @ 5 pm est
Order Cutoff date: Thursday, 11/20/25 @ 5 pm est



★ Pies
Fresh, made from scratch crusts, a Thanksgiving must!
Pumpkin
$29

Pecan
$32

Apple
$32

Key Lime
$32

NY Style Cheesecake
$35
★ Pies


★ Cakes
6" round - $35 8" round - $45
Turkey Cake (8" only)
$30

Cinnamon Swirl Cake w/ Cream Chz Icing

Spice Cake with Cream Cheese Icing

Chocolate Ganache

Salted Caramel Cake (Van or Choc)
★ Cakes


Cupcakes
Min Order of 6
Basic Christmas Sprinkle (Van/Choc)
$2.75

Premium Christmas (Van/Choc)
$3.25

Salted Caramel
$3.25

Chocolate Ganache
$3.25

Spice Cake with Cream Cheese Icing
$3.25
Cupcakes


Sides & Extras
Perfect pairings for your holidays!
Pumpkin Loaf (Plain/cream chz/choc chip)
$15

Nutty Pimento Cheese Ball
$14

Ambrosia Salad 16/32 oz ($9/18)

Sweet or Savory Pastries
Sides & Extras


★ Quiche
Easy comfort food for a crowd
Spinach & Bacon
$32

Spinach & Artichoke
$32

Southwestern Chicken
$32

Roasted Broccoli & Ham
$32

Blacken Chicken & Artichoke
$32

Ultimate Veggie
$32

Spinach, Tomato, Feta
$32
Vegetarian
★ Quiche

Menus: RestaurantsMenus
Candlecake.jpg

CUSTOM CAKES

Choose from a variety of sizes and flavors to create the perfect cake for weddings, birthdays, anniversaries and other special occasions!

We ask that cake orders be submitted no later than 72 hours before a cake is required 
*No pickup availability on Sundays

Menus: Products

CUSTOM CAKES

Cake Size & Pricing Guide

See cake cutting guide for serving yield options


6” Round Cake

serves 6-10 • 35.00 without filling • 40.00 with filling

8” Round Cake

serves 8-14 • 45.00 without filling • 50.00 with filling

10” Round Cake

serves 12-25 • 90.00 without filling • 105.00 with filling

12” Round Cake

serves 30-56 • 170.00 without filling • 185.00 with filling

Quarter Sheet

serves 24 • 60.00 without filling • 75.00 with filling

Half Sheet

serves 54 • 125.00 without filling • 145.00 with filling

Full Sheet

serves 96 • 215.00 without filling • 255.00 with filling

Number Cakes (one number)

serves 12-18 • $60. 00 • No filling options



Tiered Cakes

Servings for tiered cakes are cut ‘event style’ and are smaller than a traditional size cake serving. 

Serving Size: 5" high x 2" deep x 1' width

*each reception site may cut the cake slightly differently and may be a question for you to ask them

6” & 8” Round Tiered Cake

serves 24 • 110.00 without filling • 135.00 with filling

6” & 10” Round Tiered Cake

serves 39 • 160.00 without filling • 185.00 with filling

8” & 10” Round Tiered Cake *serving size includes both tiers for those choosing not to save the top tier

serves 63 • 180.00 without filling • 205.00 with filling

8” & 12” Round Tiered Cake *serving size includes both tiers for those choosing not to save the top tier

serves 80 • 200.00 without filing • 225.00 with filling

6”/8”/12” Round Tiered Cake

serves 80 • 275.00 without filling • 310.00 with filling

IMG_5615.jpg

NUMBER CAKES

Our best selling cake -- the perfect centerpiece for your big celebration. Completely custom and completely beautiful!

One Number

serves 12-18 • 60.00 

Two Numbers

serves 24-36 • 120.00

IMG_7123_edited_edited.jpg

BOOZY CAKES

Also a best seller, these BOOZY cakes make adult birthdays even more fun! Top it with your alcohol of choice and enjoy!

*Must be 21 or older to order

6” Round Cake

serves 6-10 • 70.00 without filling • 75.00 with filling

8” Round Cake

serves 8-14 • 80.00 without filling • 90.00 with filling

Liquor Options (3 mini bottles Included in cost)

*Customer may supply their own bottles if they want a different option

Fireball, Jack, Titos

Menus: Products

READY TO ORDER?

Menus: Text
Menus: Pro Gallery

Subscribe Form

Thanks for submitting!

850-899-9229

©2019 by Bayside Bakery. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page